Ulta Beauty’s stock turns positive for the year as analysts really liked their earnings

Ulta beat third-quarter consensus estimates for profit, sales and same-store sales and tightened its guidance by raising the low end of the range, a move typically viewed as bullish. The retailer said traffic trends were healthy and it expanded its loyalty program to 42.2 million members.

Raymond James reiterated its strong buy rating on Ulta’s stock and $500 price target, which is about 6% above the current price.

The beat was a positive surprise as investors were concerned about a margin miss and risk of lowered guidance heading into the release of the numbers, said analyst Olivia Tong.

“Gross margin declined 130 basis points year-over-year while operating margin was -230bp y/y, with gross margin better than expected due to higher other income (which includes credit card income and Target royalty fees), shrink that stayed stable, and greater fixed cost leverage due to the sales beat, offset by investments in digital and supply chain,” Tong wrote in a note to clients.

Shrink refers to lost items either because of error or theft. Retailers have complained a lot this year about organized gangs targeting stores.

Read also: Il Makiage parent Oddity’s stock soars 12% after earnings top estimates and company raises guidance

Other positives are that the cost base now accounts for the higher impact of shrink, that three quarters of the company’s network of stores have been updated with new fragrance fixtures to deter theft, and investments in digital store infrastructure and enterprise resource planning systems that started in fiscal 2023 should be completed next year, she said.

D.A. Davidson reiterated its buy rating on the stock, and said the report ticked all the boxes. Ulta has been one of the more controversial names in its coverage space this year, wrote analysts led by Michael Baker.

“The bears had been winning with the stock down 9.2% versus the SPDR S&P 500 Retail exchange-traded fund
XRT
up 6.9% and the equal weighted S&P 500 up 4.6%, said Baker. “But, we think the third-quarter results, call and call back did a lot to ease investor concerns on
a number of topics, which should lead to a relief rally for the share.”

See: Estée Lauder’s stock plunges toward a 6-year low after profit outlook falls well below forecasts

At Oppenheimer, analysts led by Rupesh Parikh recommended taking advantage of continued volatile trade from here, predicting that gains may fade.

Ulta remains a top pick for Oppenheimer, which has an outperform rating on the stock, the equivalent of buy.

The stock is also a top pick at TD Cowen, among analysts led by Oliver Chen.

“Going forward, we believe Ulta needs to increase cross-category customer purchasing trends and accelerate digital marketing investments, which are essential to productivity, margins, and inventory and product execution,” said Chen.

Otherwise, the company could lose share to rival Sephora, a unit of LVMH Moët Hennessy Louis Vuitton
MC,
-1.44%,
which has a younger customer and more premium appeal, he said.

The stock is up 0.5% in the year to date, while the S&P 500
SPX,
-0.01%
has gained 19%.

Read also: E.l.f.’s stock jumps 10% on earnings, revenue beat; strong guidance